An S-REIT is a REIT listed on the Singaporean stock exchange. This article concerns industrial and logistic REITs listed in Singapore and also owning properties there. Most of such properties are built on land leased from the Singaporean government. These land leases are relatively short, 30 to 60 years, and part of that time has already passed. The remaining time is expressed as the Weighted Average Land Lease Expiry, which I will shorten as WALL-E, like in the namesake movie.
When the land lease of a particular property has expired, the REIT owning that property has to demolish it and return the land to the government. The REIT may also manage to extend the land lease, but it must pay a large lease payment. It is really a lose-lose dilemma for the REIT. This WALL-E issue does not get much exposure in the media. This may be because the weighted expiry is still 30 years or more in the future, which is an eternity for most of us.
Still, it is the elephant in the room for me. Imagine the worst-case scenario where a REIT can not extend any of its land leases after 30 years. The impact on the REIT valuation is like a discounted cash flow calculation without a terminal value. If you are unfamiliar with these calculations, let me assure you that it dramatically decreases the value. Another way to think about it: you should at least get a 3.33% dividend yield per year just to be compensated for the fact that a year of the properties' earnings potential has been lost. Only the yield above 3.33% is what you truly earn.
The best Singaporean finance blogger Kyith Ng wrote about this issue in 2011 and concluded:
"It will be prudent to value a REIT as if this is a non-perpetual asset with a finite lifespan and calculate the internal rate of return as accordingly."
As Kyith Ng mentions in this article, the JTC Corporation is responsible for either extending a land lease or terminating it on behalf of the Singaporean government. Looking at historical cases, it seems that JTC will usually renew a land lease, but it might not do so when there are redevelopment plans for the area where an industrial property is located. Thus, JTC's decisions seem to be driven by urban planning motives rather than attempts to maximize profits. It may not be as bad as it looks for the REITs.
Even so, I am annoyed by the WALL-E issue. I do not feel I really own an asset if it must be returned within 30 years. Funny enough, I don't have this concern when a lease expires in 60 years or more. The expiring land lease issue could get increasing media attention as we get closer to the expiry dates of more and more properties. In a few years, the threat might be felt as more pressing and could influence the share prices of REITs. At least one S-REIT manager seems to share this concern...
5. Rebalancing of portfolio to freehold assets, whilst not compromising on growth:
a. With our Singapore properties, accounting for 60.5% of our portfolio by valuation, held through Jurong Town Corporation (JTC) on a leasehold basis, it is prudent that we progressively rebalance AA REIT’s portfolio to longer tenure or freehold properties to minimise the future impact of a shortening land tenure.
(AIMS APAC REIT, Annual Report 2022, page 8)
The WALL-E issue affects S-REITs with industrial properties in Singapore, like ESR-LOGOS REIT, AIMS APAC REIT, and Sabana REIT. It is much lesser an issue for S-REITS with offices, hotels, and malls, which are sectors where land leases tend to be much longer. It is also not an issue for industrial S-REITs like Daiwa House Logistics (Japan) and Frasers L&C (Australia, Europe), which, although listed in Singapore, are active in countries where land lease expiry is very long or properties are typically on freehold land. That said, there are other countries, such as Vietnam and China, where land leases are also relatively short. S-REITs like CapitaLand China Trust and EC World REIT may be impacted in these cases.
In my portfolio, the WALL-E issue concerns ESR-LOGOS REIT, AIMS APAC REIT, Sabana REIT, CapitaLand China Trust and China Merchants REIT in Hong Kong. I sold all of these.
No comments:
Post a Comment